diff --git a/app/Services/WhatsAppProxyService.php b/app/Services/WhatsAppProxyService.php
index 406ecbd..580fdb8 100644
--- a/app/Services/WhatsAppProxyService.php
+++ b/app/Services/WhatsAppProxyService.php
@@ -16,7 +16,8 @@ class WhatsAppProxyService
         //"https://botmasa.intaleq.xyz/send", // mayar
         //"https://botmasa2.intaleq.xyz/send", // shad 
         //"https://bootride.intaleq.xyz/send", // ramat bus
-        "https://bot5.intaleq.xyz/send", // shahd
+        "https://bot3.intaleq.xyz/send", // shahd
+        "https://bot5.intaleq.xyz/send", // bot5 from postman
         //"https://whatsapp.tripz-egypt.com/send" // tripz
     ];
 
@@ -67,9 +68,8 @@ class WhatsAppProxyService
 
         $responseData = json_decode($response, true);
         
-        // التحقق من حالة الرد (يمكنك تخصيصه حسب هيكل رد البوت الخاص بك)
-        if (isset($responseData['error']) && $responseData['error']) {
-             error_log("[WhatsAppProxyService] API Error on $url: " . json_encode($responseData));
+        if (!isset($responseData['success']) || $responseData['success'] !== true) {
+             error_log("[WhatsAppProxyService] API Error on $url: " . $response);
              return false;
         }
 
diff --git a/app/modules_app/auth/mobile_request_otp.php b/app/modules_app/auth/mobile_request_otp.php
index ca41dea..1616574 100644
--- a/app/modules_app/auth/mobile_request_otp.php
+++ b/app/modules_app/auth/mobile_request_otp.php
@@ -82,8 +82,8 @@ $message = "رمز التحقق لتطبيق مُصادَق:\n*{$otp}*\n\nصال
 $smsSent = $whatsappService->sendMessage($phone, $message);
 
 if (!$smsSent) {
-    error_log("WARN: Failed to send OTP WhatsApp to phone hash: {$phoneHash}");
-    // Still return success to not reveal info, but log the issue
+    error_log("ERROR: Failed to send OTP WhatsApp to phone: {$phone}");
+    json_error('عذراً، فشل في إرسال رمز التحقق. الرجاء التأكد من صحة رقم الواتساب الخاص بك والمحاولة مرة أخرى.', 500);
 }
 
 // Log for development (REMOVE IN PRODUCTION!)